Suppose that $A$ is singular, is $A^3 + A^2 + A$ singular as well?
If $A$ is singular, is $A^3+A^2+A$ singular?
10
$\begingroup$
linear-algebra
matrices
-
1I would think of that this way: $A$ is a linear transformation from $\mathbb R^n$ to $\mathbb R^n$ that squashes at least one dimension. If you apply this transformation multiple times, it will still squash that dimension. Therefore, that sum is also singular. – 2012-11-18
-
0Since already answered, let's just add for completeness than any polynomial $p(A)$ is also singular. – 2012-11-18
-
3At least if $p$ does not have a constant term. – 2012-11-19
4 Answers
33
Since $A$ is singular, it has a non-trivial kernel. Let $v$ be a non-zero vector killed by $A$.
Show that $A^3+A^2+A$ kills $v$ too.
-
16This sounds like the plot for a good action movie. – 2012-11-18
31
$A$ is singular hence $|A|=0$ thus: $$|A^{3}+A^{2}+A|=|A(A^{2}+A+I)|=|A||A^{2}+A+I|=0\cdot|A^{2}+A+I|=0$$
hence $A^{3}+A^{2}+A$ is also singular
-
2Earned a badge for this answer :) – 2012-11-18
-
0This makes so much more sense than the current 'top' answer. Well done for clarity. :) – 2012-11-18
-
1@Noldorin. I do not agree. This is correct and easy of course, but relies on a few theorems (Singular = zero determinant, multpilicity of the determinant). The other solution requires nothing. – 2012-11-18
-
0Thank you Noldorin, I really like Mariano answer and as well. as anonymous said it is more basic, and is quite easy as well :) – 2012-11-18
-
0@Belgi: Indeed, there is nothing wrong with Mariano's answer. But it relies on terminology like "kernel" (not usually covered in introductory linear algebra courses) and "kill a vector" (never seen this). Maybe just a British/European thing though. In any case, I think the more steps the better, especially for more 'basic' questions. :) – 2012-11-18
-
0@anonymous: There other relies on even more things, as I hint above. The definition of "kernel", "kill" (a vector), and the first sentence relies on a theorem, at least insofar as a proposition is one. – 2012-11-18
13
If $A$ is singular, then $AB$ is singular too, for any choice of $B$. Just put $B=A^2+A+I$.
-
0@Amihai: edited :-) – 2012-11-18
4
A square matrix is singular if and only if there exists a nonzero vector that maps to zero when transformed by the matrix.
Let $A\in\mathbb{R}^\mathit{n{\times}n}$ be singular. Then there exists $x\in\mathbb{R}^n$ such that $x\neq0$ and $Ax=0$. Thus $(A^3+A^2+A)x=(A^2+A+I)Ax=(A^2+A+I)0=0$. Therefore $A^3+A^2+A$ is singular.