2
$\begingroup$

Passengers try repeatedly to get a seat reservation in any train running between two stations until they are successful. If there is 40% chance of getting reservation in any attempt by a passenger, then the average number of attempts that passengers need to make to get a seat reserved is ?

  • 0
    It's a geometric distribution. Do you have an expression for determining the mean of a random variable with a geometric distribution?2017-02-23

1 Answers 1

0

First, think about it like this:

Since 40% of people are successful at getting a reserved train seat, 60% of people aren't. The 60 % of the people who were unsuccessful try again, and $0.6\cdot 0.6 = 0.36$, or 36% fail again. This continues, but there will always be a small percent of people who are unsuccessful at getting a train ticket, but those people don't matter.

Median

The first time, 40% are successful, and the second time, $100-36 = 64$% are now successful, including the 40% who are successful the first time.

This means that the median person will succeed after 2 attempts.

Mean

The Mean is a little bit more tricky, but we can approximate.

  • The first time, $40$% were successful.

  • The second time, $64-40 = 24$% were successful.

  • The third time, after multiplying again, $21.6$% were unsuccessful, so $100-21.6$ = $78.4,$ and $78.4-64 = 14.4$% were successful.

You might notice a trend. $\frac {40}{24} = \frac {5}{3}$, and $\frac {24}{14.4} = \frac {5}{3}$. Assuming this continues, we can calculate the mean.

  • After counting the first three trips, the average is 1.312.

  • Counting only the first five trips, the average is (about) 1.9168.

  • After ten trips, the average is (about) 2.4244.

  • After 25 trips, the average is (about) 2.4999.

  • After 100 trips, the average is (about) 2.5.

We can say that the mean is 2.5.

I used Java Eclipse to calculate Mean. The code is here.

public static double Calc(int x) {
    double answer = 0;
    double power = 0.4;
    for (int i = 1; i < x + 1; i++) {
        answer += i * power;
        power = power * 0.6;
    }
    return answer;
}
  • 0
    Although unrealistic, the problem asserts that there is a *constant* $40\%$ probability for success on *any* attempt. Don't make the problem out to be harder than it is.2017-02-23
  • 0
    Yes, but there is a $40$% chance _until they are successful._ So if you succeed at reserving a seat, you stop reserving one.2017-02-23
  • 0
    Thank you. Suppose this question is asked and as you rightly said, the answer comes out to be 2.5. Do I keep it at 2.5 or round it off to 3 as the number of attempts must be an integer ? Basically, this is my doubt. I'm stuck between 2 options - whether to mark 2.5 as an answer or 3. It would be great if you can clarify this. @ETSPTQ2017-02-24
  • 0
    I think the average would be put at 2.5. For example, if you had the average of 4 and 5, you would get 4.5, instead of rounding to 5.2017-02-24