2
$\begingroup$

Find generators of the multiplicative group of $\mathbb{F}_9$

I construct $\mathbb{F}_9=\frac{\mathbb{Z}_3[x]}{\langle x^2-2 \rangle}$

I know elements in $\mathbb{F}_9$ take the form $ax+b$ where $a,b \in \mathbb{Z}_3$.

Then how to find all generators for the multiplicative group of $\mathbb{F}_9$?

  • 0
    Maybe use $1,x$ as the generators since each element is a linear combination of these two.2017-02-05
  • 0
    @coffeemath: I am fairly sure that the OP is looking for a (single) generator of the multiplicative group. After all, the multiplicative group of a finite field is always cyclic, so those (aka primitive elements) exist. This is a standard exercise when studying finite fields. I'm also fairly sure this particular case has been handled on our site.2017-02-05
  • 0
    [This](http://math.stackexchange.com/q/534770/11619) is the first match I found. Not a very good one...2017-02-05
  • 0
    [This](http://math.stackexchange.com/q/373276/11619) is much better. Andreas Caranti gives the same elegant answer there that N.S. posted here.2017-02-05

4 Answers 4

1

Perhaps exactly the same answer as everybody else’s, but in different words:

Since $2\equiv-1\pmod3$, you’re adjoining $i$ to $\Bbb F_3$. You know that $\{\pm1,\pm i\}$ aren’t generators, so use $1+i$ as a generator, and let’s call it $g$. Direct hand calculation shows that $g^3=1-i$, $g^5=-1-i$, and $g^7=2+i$. These four are the generators of $\Bbb F_9^\times$.

3

There are only eight elements in the multiplicative group of $\mathbb{F}_9$, and since the group is isomorphic to $\mathbb{Z}/8\mathbb{Z}$ which has four generators, just guessing some element and checking if it's a generator isn't too bad of an idea. You only have to verify that your guess doesn't have order two or four, and you are done.

In the quotient where $\mathbb{F}_9$ is constructed as $\mathbb{F}_3[x]/\langle x^2-2 \rangle$, I've got that the element corresponding to $x+2$ generates the whole group because it has order greater than four. $$\begin{align} \\(x+2)^1 = \;&x+2 \\(x+2)^2 = \;&x \\(x+2)^3 = \;&2x+2 \\(x+2)^4 = \;&2 \\(x+2)^5 = \;&\dotsb \end{align}$$

And you can find the other generators through trial and error similarly.

  • 1
    Good, $+1$. But once you have one generator $X$, you have them all, since the others are $X^m$ for all the $m$ relatively prime to the order of your (cyclic) group. No “trial and error” needed.2017-02-06
2

Since the multiplicative group has order $8$, every element has order $1,2,4,8$. Therefore, any non-generator has order $1,2,4$ and hence is a solution to $$Y^4=1$$ You know that $1,2$ are the two solutions to $Y^2-1=0$ and if you figure the two solutions to $Y^2+1=0$, by elimination, everything else is a generator.

By construction $$X^2+1=X^2-2 =0$$ therefore $Y= \pm X$ are the two elements of order $4$.

2

Here's what you can also do.

Because there are eight non-zero elements in $\Bbb{F}_9$ you are looking for an eighth root of unity. Let's draw a parallel to the case of complex numbers, and see what's cooking.

In $\Bbb{C}^*$ an eighth root of unity is given by $$ \zeta_8=e^{\pi i/4}=\cos(\pi/4)+i\sin(\pi/4)=\frac{1+i}{\sqrt2}. $$ So it makes sense to try and identify substitutes for $i$ and $\sqrt2$ in your field.

Because $x^2-2=x^2+1$, we know that $u:=x+\langle x^2-2\rangle$ can serve in the role of $i$. After all, $u^2=-1$. Wait a second! Because $-1=2$, $u$ can also serve in the role of $\sqrt2$! So this is plain sailing! We get $$ \zeta_8=\frac{1+u}u=\frac1u+1 $$ as a candidate. As $u^4=1$, we see that $u^3=u^2\cdot u=-u$ is the reciprocal $1/u$.

So $$\zeta_8=-u+1$$ should work. Let's check: $$ \zeta_8^2=(1-u)^2=1-2u+u^2=(1+u^2)-2u=(1-1)+u=u. $$ As we already know that $u$ is of order four, we can conclude that our $\zeta_8$ is of order eight and hence a generator.

Altogether there are $\phi(8)=4$ generators. You get the others by using a different subsitute for $\sqrt{-1}$ and $\sqrt2$ in the above calculation. Just pick any sign combination in $i=\pm u$ and $\sqrt2=\pm u$, and the formula $\zeta_8=(1+i)/\sqrt2$ will give you a generator.

  • 0
    Sorry, I couldn't resist the temptation to improvise. May be I've been listening to too much jazz lately. OTOH [this **IS** beautiful](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aZ875UjGDuM).2017-02-05
  • 0
    I like the answer as well as the music.2017-02-05