2
$\begingroup$

Let $b\in\mathbb{R}$, prove or disprove that the improper integral $$ \int_0^\infty x^b \cos(e^x)dx$$ converges.

I used Wolfram Alpha to compute several values of $b$, it seems that for $b\geq 0$ this integral converges and $b<0$ it does not. But I don't know how to prove or disprove it. Any hint would be appreciated.

2 Answers 2

4

The oscillatory behavior of the integral is really pesky, so we need some control over this. A well-known trick is to perform integration by parts to facilitate cancellation and thus improve the speed of convergence.

To this end, we first split the integral into two parts: for $a = \log(3/2)$ and $\epsilon < a < R$, we have

$$ \int_{\epsilon}^{R} x^b \cos (e^x) \, dx = \int_{\epsilon}^{a} x^b \cos (e^x) \, dx + \int_{a}^{R} x^b \cos (e^x) \, dx =: I_1(\epsilon) + I_2(R). $$


  • Integral $I_1(\epsilon)$. We find that $0 < \cos(\tfrac{3}{2}) \leq \cos(e^x) \leq 1$ for $x \in [0, a]$ and hence

    $$ \cos(\tfrac{3}{2}) \int_{\epsilon}^{a} x^b \, dx \leq I_1(\epsilon) \leq \int_{\epsilon}^{a} x^b \, dx $$

    Taking $\epsilon \downarrow 0$, we find that $I_1(\epsilon)$ converges if and only if $b > -1$.

  • Integral $I_2(R)$. Write $x^b \cos(e^x) = (x^b e^{-x}) \cdot (e^x \cos(e^x))$. Then by integration by parts,

    $$ I_2(R) = R^b e^{-R} \sin (e^R) - a^b e^{-a} \sin(e^a) + \int_{a}^{R} (x^b - bx^{b-1})e^{-x} \sin (e^x) \, dt. $$

    Notice that this converges for any $b$ as $R \to \infty$, since the integrand decays exponentially.


Therefore the improper integral converges if and only if $b > -1$.

1

We may simplify Sangchul Lee's (perfectly fine) approch.

If we substitute $x=\log t$, we get: $$ I = \int_{1}^{+\infty}\frac{\left(\log t\right)^b}{t}\,\cos(t)\,dt $$ and assuming the integrand function is integrable in a right neighbourhood of $1$, the integral is converging by Dirichlet's test, since $\cos(t)$ has a bounded primitive and $\frac{\left(\log t\right)^b}{t}$ is decreasing to zero from some point on. So we just need to ensure integrability in a right neighbourhood of $1$, where the integrand function is $(t-1)^b (\cos(1)+o(1))$. That means the original integral is convergent iff $\color{red}{b>-1}$.