1
$\begingroup$

Is there a way to solve this equation for x?

$$\sqrt{x^2+8}-x-4\arctan\left(\frac{x+3}{x^2+x+6}\right) = 0$$

Numerically, I get $x \approx 1.39$, but is there a way I can get an exact solution?

  • 0
    I've converted your equation to LaTeX.2011-07-31

2 Answers 2

6

The solutions can't be algebraic numbers, because if $x$ was algebraic the same would be true of $y = (\sqrt{x^2+8} - x)/4 $ and $z = (x+3)/(x^2 + x + 6)$. Now your equation says $\tan y = z$, and thus $\cos^2 y = \frac{1}{z^2+1}$, so $\cos y$ would be algebraic. But by Lindemann's theorem $\cos y$ is transcendental for any nonzero algebraic $y$.

  • 0
    +1 I did not think the theory about the existence of algebraic solutions is so strong.2011-08-01
2

Thanks to Wims Function Calculator, the solution is $$ x \approx 1.39370747885618057089248282982, $$ and is not recognized by the Inverse Symbolic Calculator.

EDIT: Wims Function Calculator further gives $$ x \approx 1.3937074788561805708924828298190336450650412142437367971287022786222374715488762515547338431838298094439414865124475411133191132591019104894926923243497788034792713333649381694869738035510413209296893. $$ However, the result from the Inverse Symbolic Calculator indicates that a "closed-form" solution is not likely to exist.

  • 2
    I don't think this answers the question of the OP.2011-07-31
  • 2
    It answers the question in the negative.2011-07-31
  • 0
    @Dave: Thanks for pointing this out.2011-07-31
  • 1
    It's very unlikely that a closed-form solution to this type of equation exists. On the other hand, the Inverse Symbolic Calculator doesn't really rule out moderately complicated "closed-form" numbers. For example, there is no match to $\arctan(\sin(2)+\cos(3)+\tan(4))$.2011-07-31
  • 0
    @Robert, indeed, good point. Still, it is helpful for the OP to know that, in the present case, ISC rules out simple solutions (loosely speaking, of course).2011-07-31