0
$\begingroup$

G is a group acting on S. H is a subgroup of G and let s be anything in S. Is it true that the order of s under action of G is divisible by the order of s under action of H?

  • 5
    Can you tell us what you've already tried? And what concepts/techniques/theoerems you think might be involved?2011-05-16
  • 0
    that its true if every action of G is unique. $|G|$/$|G_s|$=$m|H|/k|H_s|$2011-05-16
  • 0
    The stabilizer $H_s$ of $s$ in $H$ is exactly the intersection $G_s \cap H$. So your statement is reduced to ask if $[H \cap G:H \cap G_s] / [G:G_s]$. Any ideas on how to go further?2011-05-16

1 Answers 1

4

If G is the symmetric group on n letters, then the orbit of s has exactly n elements. Saying that HG means that H is a permutation group on n letters. Does every permutation group on n letters have orbits that are divisors of n?

Perhaps check n = 3 to start. A similar investigation n = 5 should also be instructive.