1
$\begingroup$

In his paper "Examples of Calabi-Yau 3-manifolds with complex multiplication", Jan Christian Rohdes claims that the surface $S \subset \mathbb{P}^3$, with variables $(y_2: y_1: x_1: x_0)$, given by the following equation is smooth

$(y_2^3-y_1^3)y_1+(x_1^3-x_0^3)x_0=0$

He says: "By using partial derivatives of the defining equation, one can easily verify that $S$ is smooth". However, the equation and its partial derivatives seem to vanish at all points with $y_1=x_0=0$. Where am I making a mistake?

Thanks for your help!

  • 4
    Your mistake is that the partial derivative with respect to $y_1$ is $y_2^3-4y_1^3$, and does not vanish just because $y_1=x_0=0$ . Actually Rhodes is right : his surface $S$ is smooth.2012-05-15
  • 1
    This is a bit late, but let me point out that the author's family name is _Rohde_, with no letter 's' in sight.2013-05-06

2 Answers 2