1
$\begingroup$

Are there rules for answering this question:

$f(x)$ is a smooth function that's always increasing without bound, and $g(x)$ is a smooth function that always decreases from 1, approaching zero but never equaling it. $\sum_{x=1}^nf(x)$ diverges as n approaches infinity. But we know for sure that $\sum_{x=1}^ng(x)$ converges as n approaches infinity. Will $\sum_{x=1}^nf(x)\cdot g(x)$ converge or diverge? $f(x)$ and $g(x)$ are positive for all $x\ge 1$.

  • 0
    For the sums, $f$ and $g$ only need to be defined at the integers, in which case what do we make of derivatives?2012-10-22
  • 1
    Note also that if $f$ is bounded, then $\sum fg$ converges.2012-10-22
  • 0
    But can we use derivatives if $f$ and $g$ are smooth?2012-10-22
  • 0
    I can see that $\sum fg$ diverges if $f$ is bounded, but what I really mean is that $f$ is the kind of thing whose values smoothly get bigger and bigger, and $g$ is the kind of thing whose values smoothly get smaller and smaller. (I know $g$ could still diverge under that condition, but it doesn't.) And I thought derivatives could be used to establish that $f$'s values get bigger "more powerfully" than those of $g$ get smaller, which would mean that $\sum fg$ diverges.2012-10-22
  • 1
    No, $\sum fg$ *converges* if $f$ is bounded. Also, if $f$ gets bigger and $g$ gets smaller, then $f'(x)\gt0\gt g'(x)$, so your "if $f'(x)\lt g'(x)$" hypothesis is never met. More generally, I suggest you look at some examples $f(x)=x^a$, $g(x)=x^{-b}$, to see what kinds of behavior can occur, and what conditions you really mean to impose on the derivatives.2012-10-22
  • 0
    I'm sorry, that is a typo, I did mean *converges*.2012-10-23

1 Answers 1