1
$\begingroup$

I have been looking at this for five minutes, no clue what to do.

$$\lim_{r\to 9} \frac {\sqrt{r}} {(r-9)^4}$$

  • 0
    (You mean $r$, not $t$, right?) Are you sure that's the problem? It's of the form $3/0$ as written.2012-02-06
  • 0
    do you mean "$r$ approaches 9"?2012-02-06

3 Answers 3

3

Hint: If $r$ is close to 9, then the numerator $\sqrt r$ is close to 3 and the denominator, $(r-9)^4$, is positive and close to 0. So, if you take a number close to 3 and divide by a small positive number, what do you get?

If you take numbers appoaching 3 and divide by small positive numbers approaching 0, what do you get?




Look at some specific values: $$ \matrix{r& \quad\sqrt r\qquad&\qquad (r-9)^4\qquad & {\sqrt r\over (1-9)^4} \cr 9.1&\approx3 &.1^4 &\approx{3\over .1^4}=3\cdot 10,000 \cr 9.01&\approx3 &.01^4 &\approx{3\over .01^4}=3\cdot 10^8 \cr 9.001&\approx3 &.001^4 &\approx{3\over .001^4}=3\cdot 10^{12} \cr 8.9&\approx3 &(-.1)^4 &\approx{3\over .1^4}=3\cdot 10,000 \cr 8.99&\approx3 &(-.01)^4 &\approx{3\over .01^4}=3\cdot 10^8 \cr 8.999&\approx3 &(-.001)^4 &\approx{3\over .001^4}=3\cdot 10^{12} \cr } $$

Note the closer $r$ is to 9, the bigger $\sqrt r\over (r-9)^4$ becomes. So the limit is infinite.

Note also, please, that because the denominator is being raised to an even power, it is always positive.

The limit $\displaystyle\lim\limits_{r\rightarrow9} {\sqrt r\over (r-9)^3}$ is quite different, and in fact does not exist.

  • 0
    That line of thinking doesn't really make any sense to me at all. It isn't how things really work. For example doing that on this problem http://math.stackexchange.com/questions/106164/finding-a-limit-with-a-cube/106168#106168 causes a lot of problems. You would assume the answer is 2/0 which it is not.2012-02-06
  • 0
    @Jordan: You're misreading the situation. We have $(-1)^3+1=0$, not $=2$ like you think.2012-02-06
  • 3
    @Jordan, it doesn't work there, because you wind up with $0/0$ in that case (or "something small divided by something small", which does not lead you anywhere). Here everything is fine: the numerator is "more or less 3" and the denominator is small and positive (the "positive" is important). 3 divided by something small gets you something big...2012-02-06
2

The limit is $+\infty$ because the numerator approaches a positive number and the denominator approaches $0$ from above. Sometimes one says the limit "doesn't exist" when one means there is no real number that is the limit, so you could put it that way.

2

Replacing $r$ by $r-9$, this becomes $\lim_{r\to 0} \frac {\sqrt{r+9}} {r^4} $. As was said, the numerator goes to 3 and the denominator goes to 0, so the quotient goes to $\infty$.