I am trying to estimate $(1.999)^4$, so I set up the problem like this. $$y=x^4 ,$$ $$x=2 ,$$ $$dx=.001.$$ Then I find the derivative of $f(x)$ which is $4x^3$ and multiply that by $dx$ which is $.001$. This gives me an incorrect answer.
Differential to estimate a number
4 Answers
Why not just get the exact answer?
$1.999^4 = (2-0.001)^4 = 2^4 - 4\times2^3\times0.001 + 6\times2^2\times0.001^2 - 4\times2\times0.001^3 + 0.001^4$
$= 16 - 0.032+0.000024-0.000000008+0.000000000001 = 15.968023992001$
Just thought I'd point out that you don't need a calculator. The $1, 4, 6, 4, 1$ of course come from Pascal's triangle. And yeah, $dx$ and $\Delta x$ both mean difference or change but one is infinitesimally small and more conceptual while the other is finite and definite (finite and de-finite... sounds like a contradiction).
-
3Of course you're right in this example, but there are other cases where it's unnecessary and/or infeasibly complicated to do the exact calculation. – 2011-10-05
-
0Lol, yeah I know I'm just being a douche but figured some people might not realise it's actually pretty easy to be exact in this case :) – 2011-10-05
First, $dx = -0.001$, not $0.001$. Now $dy = 4x^3 dx$, so when you change $x$ by a small amount $dx$, you change $y$ by approximately $4x^3 dx$. In your problem $$4x^3 dx = 4(2^3)(-0.001) = -0.032;$$ this is the (approximate) amount by which you change $y$ when you move from $x=2$ to $x=2+dx=1.999$.
$\qquad$(1) What is $y$ when $x=2$?
$\qquad$(2) If you change that $y$ value by $-0.032$, what do you get?
That is your approximation to $1.999^4$.
-
0y is 16 when x is 2. 15.968 Is this the proper way to do the problem? So y= y-dy? – 2011-10-05
-
0@Jordan: Yes, apart from carefully distinguishing $d$’s from $\Delta$’s. That should be $y+dy$, though: you always add the differential in these problems. Finally, to avoid using $y$ for two different things at once, you should write $y\approx y_0+dy$. Here $y_0$ means the particular value of $y$ from which you’re starting; that’s $16$ in this case. – 2011-10-05
-
0@Jordan: By the way, if you place the cursor on a formula, right-click, and click on *Show Source*, you can see the $\LaTeX$ code that was used to produce it; if you enclose that within dollar signs, you get the nice-looking displays. – 2011-10-05
The notation you use is a little non-standard (in fact, technically wrong). I will use $\Delta x$ to denote what you call $dx$.
Imagine the process like this. Suppose you are originally at $x=2$ and you move to $x+\Delta x = 1.999$. First of all, solving for $\Delta x$, we get $\Delta x = - 0.001$. The negative sign is crucial; it tells you whether the "new" value $x + \Delta x$ is larger or smaller than $2$. (You missed the negative sign here.)
Whatever you are calculating after that is the change in $y$ when the argument changes from $x=2$ to $x+\Delta x = 1.999$. This is given (approximately) by: $$ \Delta y \approx f'(x) \Delta x . $$ Here in place of $f'(x)$, you should plug in $f'(2) = 4 \cdot 2^3 = \ldots$. And, of course, $\Delta x = -0.001$. Multiplying these two numbers, you can find the value of $\Delta y$.
But this is not what you were asked to calculate. This is the change in the value of the function as the argument changed from $2$ to $1.999$. You need to calculate $f(1.999)$. You can do so by: $$ f(1.999) = y+\Delta y = f(2) + \Delta y. $$ (You can understand this like: final value of the function = it's initial value + change in the function when the argument changed a little.)
You know $f(2)$, and you know $\Delta y$. Can you calculate $f(1.999)$?
Warning. You should be quite careful with the negative signs. I emphasize, again, that $\Delta x$ is negative.
-
0You’re a braver man than I: I was going to wait with the $d/\Delta$ distinction until we got the big problem sorted! :-) – 2011-10-05
-
0@Brian Yes, I am kind of torn between trying to be correct versus trying to give a useful answer. ;) Hopefully, the $d/\Delta$ distinction does not deter the OP from understanding what I say. Whether he uses it himself or not, it's up to his comfort level. – 2011-10-05
-
0I know the difference between dy and $\Delta y$ but I guess I won't even ask about x. I am not too sure what is meant by $f(1.999) = y+\Delta y \approx f(2) + \Delta y.$ – 2011-10-05
-
0@Jordan The second sign should also be equality. So $x$ changes slightly from 2 to $1.999$. What is the change in $y$? We calculated that before, and called it $\Delta y$. Now you know that the value of $f$ at $2$ is $16$. When $x$ changes now to $1.999$, it's new value (i.e., $f(1.999)$) is nothing but $f(2)$ plus whatever the change is. That's exactly what the equation is saying. – 2011-10-05
-
0So how do I write that in a formula? $y= \delta y + y$? – 2011-10-05
-
0@Jordan No, you need to decide what $x$ and $y$ are. Here $x$ is $2$, and $y$ is the corresponding value of the function $=f(2)=16$. (You are using $y$ to mean both the original and changed values of the function, which will only confuse you in the middle of the problem.) I would write it simply as $y+\Delta = y + f'(x) \Delta x$. Here $y+\Delta y$ is the value of the function at $x+\Delta x$. (Alternatively, you can write it as I have written in my answer: $f(x+\Delta x) = y + \Delta y = y + f'(x) \Delta x$. They come down to the same thing.) – 2011-10-05
-
0@Jordan Brian's suggestion of writing the original values as $x_0$ (or $y_0$) and new value as $x$ (or $y$) is also very nice. In that notation, $x_0 = 2$, $y_0=f(x_0)$, $x=2$, $y=f(x)$, and finally, $$f(y) = y_0 + \Delta y = f(x_0) + f'(x_0)\Delta x .$$ Whatever convention you follow, stick to it so that you do not get confused; that's the main thing. – 2011-10-05
-
0Okay I think I got it $10 + 1/3x^-2/3 (1)$ x=1000 and y=10.003333 – 2011-10-05
-
0@Jordan Have to go now. Perhaps you can post that as a new question? I recommend that you do as much as you can, and *show your working*. – 2011-10-05
-
0@Jordan BTW I made a small (but significant) error two comments before this. It should read: In that notation, $x_0 = 2, y_0=f(x_0), x=1.999, y=f(x)$. Note that $x$ is not the same as $x_0$, of course; $x = x_0 + \Delta x$. – 2011-10-05
$\frac{d}{dx} x^4 = 4x^3$
$\frac{d}{dx} x^4$ at $x=2$ is $32$
So $1.999^5 \approx 2^4 - (32(0.001))$