16
$\begingroup$

I have a compact selfadjoint operator $T$ on a separable Hilbert space. For some fixed orthonormal basis, the operator's diagonal is in $\ell^1(\mathbb{N})$.

Can we conclude that $T$ is trace class?

  • 3
    @Norbert: you are assumming that $T$ is diagonal in the given basis, which is not the case.2012-07-24

2 Answers 2

18

No, we cannot conclude that the operator is trace class.

For example, let a Hilbert space have orthonormal basis $e_1,f_2,e_2,f_2,e_3,f_3,\ldots$, and $T$ interchanges $e_i,f_i$, while multiplying both by a positive real $\lambda_i$. That is, in these coordinates, the matrix of $T$ is a list of diagonal blocks, with the $i$-th diagonal block being anti-diagonal $\lambda_i,\lambda_i$.

For $\lambda_i\rightarrow 0$, the operator is compact, almost from the definition.

All the diagonal entries are $0$.

The operator is self-adjoint because the matrix is symmetric real.

However, the operator is not trace class unless $\sum_i |\lambda_i|<\infty$, which easily fails for many sequences of positive reals $\lambda_i\rightarrow 0$.

Edit: It is noteworthy that the analogous characterization (I pointedly don't say "definition") of "Hilbert-Schmidt" does not depend on choice of basis. Thus, "defining" trace-class as composition of two Hilbert-Schmidt operators is sometimes usefully more intrinsic, less basis/coordinate-dependent.

  • 3
    Yes, I have wished so hard for my operator to be positive...2012-07-25
2

Disclaimer: Non-Compact Operators!

Given the Hilbert space $\ell^2(\mathbb{N})$.

Consider sum of shifts:* $A_\pm:\ell^2(\mathbb{N})\to\ell^2(\mathbb{N}):\quad A_\pm:=R\pm L$

They have finite trace: $\sum_n\langle A_\pm\delta_n,\delta_n\rangle=\sum_n0=0$

But for the shifts: $\sum_n\langle|R|\delta_n,\delta_n\rangle=\sum_n1=\infty$ $\sum_n\langle|L|\delta_n,\delta_n\rangle=\sum_n1=\infty$ Thus for the sum: $\operatorname{Tr}A_\pm<\infty\implies\operatorname{Tr}A_\mp<\infty$ Concluding counterexample.

*Shifts: Right & Left

  • 0
    Good idea with the disclaimer, thank you! :) Done!2017-01-13