2
$\begingroup$

I just started Calculus II and have been given the following problem:

Find the area inside the curves: $y = 5 - 2x^2\\y = 3x^2 \\ x = -4 \\x = 4$

I graphed the two curves on my calculator to get a rough idea of the problem but noticed that the x values aren't where the two curves cross.

I'm wondering if I should integrate on 4,-4 or if I should calculate where they cross and use those values as the minimum and maximum x values.

Thanks in advance

edit: The beggining of the problem was just about sketching the graph and drawing approximating rectangles; however the part that I was confused on was worded as such:

y = 5 - 2x^2, y = 3x^2, x = -4, x = 4

find the area S of the region

2 Answers 2

4

Draw the two parabolas (which meet at $x=\pm 1$), and the two lines. There are three finite regions in the picture. I think you are being asked to find their combined area. The issue is that in part of the picture, the parabola $y=5-2x^2$ is above the parabola $y=3x^2$, and in part of the picture, it is below $y=3x^2$. The simplest way to do the calculation is to treat these parts separately, then add up.

The "middle" region has $5-2x^2\ge 3x^2$. To find its area we calculate $\int_{-1}^1 ((5-2x^2)-3x^2)\,dx.$ The region on the "right" has $3x^2\ge 5-2x^2$. To find its area we calculate $\int_1^4 (3x^2-(5-2x^2))\,dx.$ The area of the region on the "left" can be calculated in a similar way. However, we might as well take advantage of symmetry. Now add up the three areas.

Remark: I would prefer to note the symmetry from the beginning, and observe that we can calculate the area to the right of the $y$-axis, then double. The area to the right of the $y$-axis is $\int_0^1 ((5-2x^2)-3x^2)\,dx+\int_1^4 (3x^2-(5-2x^2))\,dx. $ We could express this as a "single" integral, by noting that the area to the right of the $y$-axis is $\int_0^4\left|(5-2x^2)-3x^2\right|\,dx.$ However, the gain is illusory, since to deal with the absolute value sign, the best thing to do is to break up the integral at $x=1$.

2

If the problem asks for the area between the two curves $y=5-2x^2$ and $y=3x^2$ over the interval from $x=-4$ to $x=4$, I would understand it to mean that you’re to find the total area between the two parabolas between the lines $x=-4$ and $x=4$. In that case you’ll have three separate areas to calculate, one between $x=-4$ and $x=-1$, one between $x=-1$ and $x=1$, and one between $x=1$ and $x=4$, and you’ll want their sum.

However, it would be helpful for us to see the exact wording.

  • 0
    @Logan: The problem is badly worded, but I think that my interpretation is probably the intended one.2012-08-26