2
$\begingroup$

I'm stuck on a particular type of work and time problems.

For example,

1) A,B,C can complete a work separately in 24,36 and 48 days. They started working together but C left after 4 days of start and A left 3 days before completion of the work. In how many days will the work be completed?

A simpler version of the same type of problem is as follows:

2) A can do a piece of work in 14 days while B can do it in 21 days. They begin working together but 3 days before the completion of the work, A leaves off. The total number of days to complete the work is?

My attempt at problem 2:

A's 1 day work=1/14 and B's 1 day work= 1/21

Assume that it takes 'd' days to complete the entire work when both A and B are working together. Then,

(1/14 + 1/21)*d= 1

-> d=42/5 days.

But it is stated that 3 days before the completion of the work, A left. Therefore, work done by both in (d-3) days is:

(1/14 + 1/21)*(42/5 - 3)= 9/14

Remaining work= 1- 9/14 = 5/14 which is to be done by B alone. Hence the time taken by B to do (5/14) of the work is:

(5/14)*21 = 7.5 days.

Total time taken to complete the work = (d-3) + 7.5 = 12.9 days.

However, this answer does not concur with the one that is provided.

My Understanding of problem 1:

Problem 1 is an extended version of problem 2. But since i think i'm doing problem 2 wrong, following the same method on problem 1 will also result in a wrong answer.

Where did i go wrong?

5 Answers 5

1

You asked where you went wrong in solving this problem:

A can do a piece of work in 14 days while B can do it in 21 days. They begin working together but 3 days before the completion of the work, A leaves off. The total number of days to complete the work is?

As you said in your solution, $A$ can do $1/14$ of the job per day, and $B$ can do $1/21$ of the job per day. On each day that they work together, then, they do $\frac1{14}+\frac1{21}=\frac5{42}$ of the job. Up to here you were doing fine; it’s at this point that you went astray. You know that for the last three days of the job $B$ will be working alone. In those $3$ days he’ll do $3\cdot\frac1{21}=\frac17$ of the job. That means that the two of them working together must have done $\frac67$ of the job before $A$ left. This would have taken them

$\frac{6/7}{5/42}=\frac67\cdot\frac{42}5=\frac{36}5\text{ days}\;.$

Add that to the $3$ days that $B$ worked alone, and you get the correct total: $\frac{36}5+3=\frac{51}5=10.2\text{ days}\;.$

You worked out how long it would take them working together, subtracted $3$ days from that, saw how much of the job was left to be done at that point, and added on the number of days that it would take $B$ working alone to finish the job. But as your own figures show, $B$ actually needs $7.5$ days to finish the job at that point, not $3$, so he ends up working alone for $7.5$ days. This means that $A$ actually left $7.5$ days before the end of the job, not $3$ days before. You have to figure out how long it takes them to reach the point at which $B$ can finish in $3$ days.

Added:

1) A,B,C can complete a work separately in 24, 36 and 48 days. They started working together but C left after 4 days of start and A left 3 days before completion of the work. In how many days will the work be completed?

Here you know that all three worked together for the first $4$ days, $B$ worked alone for the last $3$ days, and $A$ and $B$ worked together for some unknown number of days in the middle. Calculate the fraction of the job done by all three in the first $4$ days and the fraction done by $B$ alone in the last $3$ days, and subtract the total from $1$ to see what fraction was done by $A$ and $B$ in the middle period; then see how long it would take $A$ and $B$ to do that much.

  • 0
    Can you please have a look at this:- http://math.stackexchange.com/questions/209842/simple-way-for-solving-generic-work-and-time-problems I had no other way of contacting you since there is no messaging system available on stack exchange.2012-10-09
0

Problem $1.)$

Let $n$ be the required number of days.

$A,B,C$'s $1$ day work is $1/24,1/36,1/48$ respectively.

Work done by $C=4/48$

Work done by $B=n/36$

Work done by $A=(n-3)/24$

Sum of all the work is $1$ which gives

$\frac{1}{12}+\frac{n}{36}+\frac{n-3}{24}=1$

Solving which you will get your answer.

Problem $2.)$ can be solved using similar approach

0

In problem 2 you are misinterpreting the phrase "$A$ left 3 days before the work was done." When you calculate it as above (3 days before the work would've been done if $A$ worked on), its wrong, as $A$ left (as you calculated) 7.5 days before the work was done.

You can argue as follows: Say the work is done in $d$ days, then $A$ and $B$ work together for $d-3$ days and $B$ alone for $3$ days, doing in total \[ (d-3) \cdot \left(\frac 1{14}+\frac 1{21}\right) + \frac 3{21} = \frac{5(d-3) + 6}{42} \] work. So we must have $5(d-3) = 36$, so $5d = 51$, that is $d = 57/5$. For 1), you can argue along the same lines.

0

A,B,C can complete a work separately in 24, 36 and 48 days. They started working together but C left after 4 days of start and A left 3 days before completion of the work. In how many days will the work be completed?

ans-- A,B AND C ONE DAY WORK=(1/24+1/36+1/48)=13/144

FOUR DAYS WORK OF A,B AND C IS =[4*(13/144)]=13/36

AFTER FOUR DAYS REMAINING WORK =[1-(13/36)]=23/36

IN LAST 3 DAYS A WORKING ALONE IS =[3*(1/24)]=1/8

REST OF WORK IS ([(23/36)-(1/8)]=37/72) DONE BY A AND B TOGETHER

A AND B ONE DAY WORK IS=[(1/24)+(1/36)]=5/72

TIME TAKEN THEM TO COMPLETE THE WORK=[(37/72)/(5/72)]=37/5

TOTAL TIME TO COMPLETE THE WORK=[(37/5)+3+4]=72/5

-1

A better approach to the problem.

Take the LCM of 14 and 21 which will give you the total amount of work. LCM (14,21) = 42.

A completes in 14 days.So he does 42/14 in 1 day.Similarly B does 42/21 in 1 day. A=3,B=2.Since A left 3 days prior to the completion of the work, so his 3 days work is absent.Lets add his 3 days pending work to the total amount of work.

In 1 day he does 3 units of work, so in 3 days he will do 9 units of work.

Total work = 42+9 = 51.

Both will now take 3+2 to complete the total work.

A+B = 51/5 = 10.2.