5
$\begingroup$

I would like to have an example (or a proof that there does not exist) of a function on the complex numbers, which for lack of a better term I'll call generalized addition, such that $x\oplus y=y\oplus x$ $(x\oplus y)\oplus z=x\oplus(y\oplus z)$ $x\oplus (\pm i\cdot x)=0$ $(ax)\oplus(bx)=(|a|+|b|)x\oplus 0$

Where $a$ and $b$ are real. Actually, it would be even nicer is the last identity could be substituted with $(ax)\oplus(bx)=f(|a|+|b|)x\oplus 0$ where $f(|a|+|b|)\ge (|a|+|b|)^\alpha$ and $\alpha\ge 1$. An example of a function that satisfies the first three identities (but not the forth one) is $x\oplus y=\sqrt(x^2+y^2)$. Is there a way to incorporate the last condition?

EDIT: Continuity would be nice, bar a(n almost necessary) branch cut.

EDIT: Changed the fourth condition since it seems to lead to a trivial contradiction.

  • 0
    Similar to the (incorrect, deleted) answer, one might consider operations of the form $a\oplus b = g^{-1}(g(a)+g(b))$. This will automatically ensure commutativity and associativity.2012-05-05

1 Answers 1

4

Suppose $x \oplus y$ is of the form $h\big(g(x) + g(y)\big)$ with $g\big(h(x)\big) = x$, which immediately guarantees commutativity and associativity: $x \oplus y = h\big(g(x) + g(y)\big) = h\big(g(y) + g(x)\big) = y \oplus x,$ $(x\oplus y)\oplus z = h\big(g(h\big(g(x) + g(y)\big))+g(z)\big) = h\big(g(x) + g(y) + g(z)\big) = h\big(g(x) + g(h\big(g(y) + g(z)\big))\big) = x\oplus(y\oplus z).$ Now let $g(x)$ be the complex number with the same modulus as $x$ and twice its argument. That is, $g(0) = 0$, and $g(x) = \lvert x\rvert e^{2i\arg x}$ when $x \ne 0$. Then we can set $h(0) = 0$ and $h(x) = \lvert x\rvert e^{i(\arg x)/2}$ otherwise. Assuming $\arg$ has range $(-\pi,\pi]$, this has a discontinuity along the negative real line, and we have $g\big(h(x)\big) = x$, but $h\big(g(x)\big) = x \operatorname{sgn} \operatorname{Re} x$. Now observe that $g(\pm ix) = e^{\pm i\pi}\lvert x\rvert e^{2i\arg x} = -g(x),$ and for real $a$, $\arg ax$ is either $\arg x$ or $\arg x \pm \pi$ depending on the sign of $a$, but in either case $g(ax) = \lvert a\rvert\lvert x\rvert e^{2i\arg x}e^{\pm2i\pi} = \lvert a\rvert g(x).$

Now we can verify the third and (original) fourth conditions: $x\oplus(\pm ix) = h\big(g(x) + g(\pm ix)\big) = h\big(g(x) - g(x)\big) = h(0) = 0.$ $(ax)\oplus(bx) = h\big(g(ax)+g(bx)\big) = h\big(\lvert a\rvert g(x) + \lvert b\rvert g(x)\big) = h\big((\lvert a\rvert + \lvert b\rvert)g(x)\big) = h\big(g((\lvert a\rvert+\lvert b\rvert)x)\big) = h\big(g((\lvert a\rvert+\lvert b\rvert)x) + g(0)\big) = (\lvert a\rvert+\lvert b\rvert)x \oplus 0.$

(I don't understand why the original fourth condition is troublesome or implies that $x \oplus 0 = 0$. Perhaps there is an error in this answer.)

  • 0
    @Ivan: If I may, I am very curious what you wanted such$a$function for.2012-05-06