24
$\begingroup$

Let $G$ be a finitely generated group and $H$ a subgroup of $G$. If the index of $H$ in $G$ is finite, show that $H$ is also finitely generated.

  • 1
    look at http://groupprops.subwiki.org/wiki/Schreier%27s_lemma2010-12-05

4 Answers 4

6

Well, the standard argument is as follows.

Let $ g \mapsto [g] \qquad (g \in G) $ be a function which is constant on all right cosets of $H,$ and we require $ [e]=e. $

It is easy to see that $ u [u]^{-1} \in H, \quad [[u]]=[u], \quad [[u]v]=[uv] \qquad (u,v \in G) \qquad \qquad (*) $ Now let $ S = \{ [g] : g \in G\} $ and $Y=Y^{-1}$ be a symmetric generating set of $G.$ Then the set $ \{ s y [sy]^{-1} : s \in S, y \in Y\} $ is a generating set of $H$ (a finite one, if both $S$ and $Y$ are finite $\iff$ the index of $H$ in $G$ is finite and $G$ is finitely generated).

For suppose that a product $y_1 \ldots y_r$ is in $H$ where $y_k \in Y$ ($k=1,\ldots,r$). Let, for example's sake, $r=3.$ Then $ y_1 y_2 y_3 = y_1 [y_1]^{-1} \cdot [y_1] y_2 [[y_1] y_2]^{-1} \cdot [[y_1] y_2] y_3 [[[y_1] y_2] y_3]^{-1} \qquad \qquad (**) $ where in the right hand side we have a product of elements of $H$ by (*), since $ [[[y_1] y_2] y_3]=[y_1 y_2 y_3]=e; $ the same $(*)$ also simplifies the right hand side of $(**)$ as $ y_1 [y_1]^{-1} \cdot [y_1] y_2 [y_1 y_2]^{-1} \cdot [y_1 y_2] y_3 [y_1 y_2 y_3]^{-1}=y_1 y_2 y_3 [y_1 y_2 y_3]^{-1}=y_1 y_2 y_3 $ Now the induction step in general must be easy.

  • 0
    Thanks for giving me the standard approach. I appreciate it.2010-12-05
27

Here's the topological argument. The fact that $G$ is finitely generated means that $G=\pi_1(K)$ for $K$ a CW-complex with finite 1-skeleton. Let $\widehat{K}$ be the covering space corresponding to $H$. Then $H=\pi_1(\widehat{K})$, and $\widehat{K}$ also has finite 1-skeleton, so $H$ is finitely generated.

  • 4
    Pete - yes, that's essentially the same proof. The fact that every group is a quotient of a free group is just the assertion that every complex has a one-skeleton.2010-12-12
20

Hint: Suppose $G$ has generators $g_1, \ldots, g_n$. We can assume that the inverse of each generator is a generator. Now let $Ht_1, \ldots, Ht_m$ be all right cosets, with $t_1 = 1$. For all $i,j$, there is $h_{ij} \in H$ with $t_i g_j = h_{ij} t_{{k}_{ij}}$, for some $t_{{k}_{ij}}$. It's not hard to prove that $H$ is generated by all the $h_{ij}$.

  • 0
    @mez It can be proved this $t$ is exactly $t_1=1$2014-08-14