0
$\begingroup$

I have a question about the Chebyshev inequality in probability. Specifically, I am concerned with the term inside the probability function.

I agree with the following: Let $Y = (X-EX)^2$. Then Y is a non-negative quantity. Therefore, Markov's inequality can be used here. I agree with the following: $P(Y > a^2) \leq \frac{EY}{a^2}$

Then, replacing Y inside the probability statement, $P((X-EX)^2 > a^2) \leq \frac{EY}{a^2}$

Note that the following four statements are true: $ |a| > b \iff a > b \vee a < -b$ $ a^2 > b^2 \iff a > b \vee a < -b$ $ a^2 < b^2 \iff -|b| < a < |b|$ $ |a| < b \iff -b < a < b$

Then, I make this statement, using the facts above (call this equation (1)): $P((X-EX)^2 > a^2) \leq \frac{EY}{a^2} \iff P(-|X-EX| < a < |X-EX|) \leq \frac{EY}{a^2} $

Note that the Chebyshev's Inequality usually leads to this (call this equation (2)): $ P(|X-EX| > a) \leq \frac{EY}{a^2}$

I am confused why my equation (1) differs from equation (2), which is found in many books.

Any help would be appreciated, thanks.

1 Answers 1

2

The inequality you gave in equation (2) is only valid for $a>0$. If you assume that $a>0$, your statement reduces to the one of your equation (2) because $-|X-EX| is always true.

Why we do this is simple, only one side of the double inequality can be relevant at a time, so there is no need to keep both. if $a<0$, then in the same way that it reduces for $a>0$, the statement $a<|X-EX|$ becomes always true.

Edit : Also, $a$ represents a distance from the expected value, so it should be positive. (Taking the negative of the distance and comparing it to a negative value is not useful)

  • 0
    That is correct. A is just shorthand for "A and B".2011-07-27