0
$\begingroup$

Suppose $G$ is a profinite group and $H$ and $K$ are subgroups with conjugate closures. Does it follow that $H$ and $K$ themselves are conjugate in $G$?

  • 0
    I now see that my question was not a good question. Non isomorphic groups can have the same profinite completion so no hope for a satisfactory answer to my question.2011-07-22

1 Answers 1

1

The question has been decided in the comments, but let me just record a specific counterexample.

Let $G = \hat{\mathbb{Z}}$ be the profinite completion of $\mathbb{Z}$. Let $H = \hat{\mathbb{Z}}$ and let $K$ be any subgroup with $\mathbb{Z} \subseteq K \subsetneq \hat{\mathbb{Z}}$. Then $H$ and $K$ have conjugate (indeed equal) closures, but are not conjugate (equivalently equal, since $G$ is abelian) in $G$. It is easy to see that there are uncountably many choices for $K$.