$X_k$'s are i.i.d. Suppose $X_k$ is symmetric and $E[|X_k|^{3/4}]<\infty$. Do we have $S_n/n \rightarrow 0$ either in probability or almost surely, where $S_n$ is the partial sum.
Weaker condition for law of large numbers
6
$\begingroup$
probability
-
0basically a random one < 1. – 2011-11-13
1 Answers
9
No.
Take the standard Cauchy distribution: $\newcommand{\rd}{\,\mathrm{d}} \mathbb E |X|^{3/4} = 2 \int_{0}^{\infty} \frac{x^{3/4}}{\pi (1+x^2)} \rd x= \csc(\pi/8) < \infty \>, $ but $S_n/n$ is equal in distribution to $X$. That is, it is also standard Cauchy no matter how large $n$ becomes.
More generally, note that this same counterexample works for any $0 < p < 1$ since $ \frac{\pi}{2} \mathbb E|X|^p = \int_{0}^\infty \frac{x^p}{1+x^2} \rd x \leq 1 + \int_{1}^\infty x^{p-2} \rd x = \frac{2-p}{1-p} < \infty \> . $
-
5Thanks. The Cauchy serves as a counterexample for *many* statements regarding probability and mathematical statistics. Usually, at least in a setting that admits continuous distributions, it's a good one to try out on any new conjecture or "result". – 2011-11-13