-2
$\begingroup$

Let $x(a)\geq1$ and $y(b)\geq1$. I have a relation $x(a) \leq k(a,b)y(b)$ for all $k(a\geq b) \geq 1$ and $x(a)=y(b)$ when $k(a=b)=1$. Can we conclude that $x(a)\geq y(b)$ ?

  • 0
    Maybe we could understand the question if you gave an example or two of numbers/functions/whatever $x,y,k$ (and $a$ and $b$?) satisfying the hypotheses of the question, and examples *not* satisfying the hypotheses.2011-08-28

1 Answers 1

1

No, it most definitely does not imply that. Indeed, try solving for both $x< k y$ and $x \le y$ at the same time for $x \ge 1 \land y \ge 1$.

For $k=2$, $ x = 3$ and $y = 5$ clearly satisfy both: $ 3 < 2 \times 5$ and $3 \le 5$.

  • 1
    It should also satisfy for $k=1$, $x=y$.2011-08-26