4
$\begingroup$

I came across the following problem on put options:

A European put with strike price $100$ expiring in $1$ year has premium $ \$ 1$ and a European put with strike price $K$ expiring in $1$ year has premium $ \$ 2$. The continuously compounded risk free interest rate is $r>1$. What is the full range of values of $K$ that results in an arbitrage opportunity.

Why do we assume that we buy the $ \$100$ put option and sell the $K$ put option? In other words our position is the following: $(\max(0, 100-S_1)-1e^{r})- (\max(0, K-S_1)-2e^{r}) >0$ which means that $K < 100+e^r$ for arbitrage.

  • 0
    It would help most readers of this site if you could explain what a "European put" is.2011-07-10

2 Answers 2

3

You raise a good point. Suppose $K=300$, for example. Then we could sell three $100$-put options and buy one $300$-put option, netting $1$ unit at time $t=0$. Our wealth at time $t=1$ will be $ e^r + \max(0,300-S_1) - 3\max(0,100-S_1). $ If $S_1\le100$, then this reduces to $ e^r + 300 - S_1 - 300 + 3S_1 = e^r + 2S_1 \ge e^r. $ If $100, then this reduces to $ e^r + 300 - S_1 \ge e^r. $ And if $S_1 > 300$, then this reduces to $e^r$. So it appears we have arbitrage at $K=300$, and the answer $K<100+e^r$ is incomplete.

  • 0
    Since we can achieve any rational ratio between the numbers of options we buy and sell, K>200 is already enough. That it's extremely unlikely isn't really an argument, since arbitrage opportunities are inherently unlikely to actually occur. The low premium of $\$1$ indicates that the current price is probably far above 100; if it's, say, 300, it's plausible that someone might assess the value of a 100 put option at $\$1$ and someone else might assess that of a 200 put option at $\$2$.2011-07-11
3

As the premium of the $K$ option is higher than the premium of the $100$ option, $K \gt 100$. If the price stays above $K$, both options expire worthless and we keep the dollar, worth $e^r$ at the end of the year. If the price falls below $100$, both are exercised and we have the $e^r+100-K$. If the price is between $100$ and $K$, say $P$, the $K$ option is exercised and we sell in the market, ending with $e^r+P-K$.If you were to buy the $K$ and sell the $100$, you would be out if the price stayed high.

  • 0
    That makes even a larger arbitrage opportunity. Errors like that are usually not considered.2011-07-10